Sunday, May 26, 2013

Betting Your Life

Why go on a search for truth in the first place? In this post I will outline why many choose not to search, what I have lost from choosing to search, and why the benefits of searching far outweigh the losses. Here is a short definition of what I mean when I say search for truth: Take the time to examine all of the relevant evidence for and against the existence of God(s), as well as for and against every worldview.

Speaking from almost 4 years of experience now, I can say that there is quite a lot to lose from spending the time to fairly and honestly search. I grew up in a religious community with a staunchly single-minded background, where evidence means little unless it supports a previously decided conclusion. Having decided to question and come to my own conclusions, I have learned that most people would rather abandon an upstart searcher than spend the time necessary to have an open dialogue, much less go on a search for themselves.

Here is a brief list of things that can be lost from going on a journey to find the truth:
  • Time. Lots and lots of time. Possibly a whole life's worth.
  • Work. It takes a great amount of energy to learn about all of the essential subject material. As one tiny example, to have a basic grasp on the Cosmological Argument (one out of man arguments) one must understand parts of Einstein's Theory of Relativity. To learn about that takes work.
  • Relationships. If someone comes from a close-minded worldview, they are likely to abandon you. This may not always be the case, but abandonment was the general trend for me (with a few amazing exceptions).
Let's say you come from a Christian household and grew up in a Christian community. You go to college and all of your close friends are Christian. Honestly considering the validity of every worldview and not coming to a conclusion as to what you think until you have examined all of the evidence will cost you your relationships with your community. What do you choose? Search for truth, or enjoy your social life?

I think that searching for truth is a much better option, because your life is at stake.

On the one hand, it is possible that hell (any version, not just the Christian version) exists. If this is the case, and you don't find out about how to avoid it, you could end up in eternal turmoil (it is possible that hell does not last forever, depending on the meaning of the Greek word "Aeonios", but an eternal hell is also a possible interpretation). The possibility of eternal stakes makes an honest search for truth infinitely worth it.

Starting to sound like Pascal's Wager? Hold on a minute- the ol' wager only applies if the choices are limited to two options- a religion or not that religion. If multiple religions come in to play, then the wager becomes watered down with each additional belief system that is added to the set of possibilities. Realizing this, most will simply discard the wager. I, however, think it is best to examine every religion and cut down the number of ones that are taken into account. This way the wager becomes re-strengthened if enough worldviews/religions are cut out (i.e. We can throw out belief in Zeus, because he obviously doesn't exist).

On the flip side, choosing Christianity, for example, means throwing your life away, not saving it. Christians are among all people most to be pitied if Christianity is invalid, according to the Apostle Paul. This means that it is not a good idea to simply throw your life away, as anyone who is actually a Christian would, if Jesus did not rise from the dead. Those who hold to Christianity without a care as to whether or not Jesus rose simply don't understand Christianity.

The same argument holds true to a greater or lesser extent to any belief system which has a cost. I do note that some belief systems do not come with significant negative side effects. If a belief has no negative side effects, it is outside the scope of this conversation. An appropriate analogy would be the administration of various kinds of drugs. If a drug has no side effects and useful benefits- such as a fish oil supplement- then go ahead and take it. If a drug has extreme side effects- such as those used for chemotherapy- it is only worth taking if it is absolutely necessary.

I suppose I just compared Christianity to chemotherapy. Good if it is absolutely needed, bad otherwise.

In addition to acquiring a certain level of eternal security (if there is an afterlife of some kind), or avoiding the costs of holding to certain religious beliefs if they turned out to be true (as is the case with many beliefs), there is the added benefit of undergoing mind-expanding exploration. I have found this type of learning to be most joyous and fulfilling.

Conclusion:

We all have a single life to live. In order to live this life to the fullest, we need to figure out what the rules of life are. If the rules are that one can live forever by believing in someone, then believe in that someone. If you can go to paradise for being a good person, be a good person. If there is no afterlife, enjoy your life as much as you possibly can, because you only have so much time to enjoy. Searching for truth allows us to figure out how to obtain the most joy.




5 comments:

  1. Not sure if this is related, but your post reminded me of this: http://i.imgur.com/mxKq3.jpg

    Thoughts?

    Cheers,
    The Grounded Unicorn

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting pic. I love Bertrand Russell!

    I agree and disagree with Russell on his point. There is a sense in which I could not commit to a belief system 100% because I will never reach 100% certainty that almost anything is true. I think that is what Russell is getting at.

    There is a different sense in which I examine commitment in this post. The situation changes if you are forced to choose between beliefs.

    For example, IF you are either going to live or die based off of something that you believe, and you have to decide on believing something either way, you have to choose.

    In that scenario, it could be a good idea to die for your beliefs is you are over 50% sure of one belief system over another. Are you going to bet your life on less than 50% instead?

    To sum up, Russell has a hidden premise of atheism within his words in that specific quote. I choose to assume openness towards the possibility of an afterlife or the lack there of. If you start with an open premise, you have to bet your life on something.

    Good to hear from you, and my the ground be as clear as the sky.

    -JTS

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good to see you back, Josh.

    You know that you just plumped for a form of hedonism? :)

    I suppose that this is consistent with someone coming from a Christian background since they talk all the time about such things as "Joy to the World" and "I am the Truth". These concepts therefore become a bit murky right from the start. Perhaps the first step for anyone embarking on a search like yours is to truly understand where they are, semantically.

    In other words, if they are looking for truth and the maximisation of joy, it'd be good to understand what "truth" and "joy" are.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Neo. Good to hear from you. =D

      I would actually consider myself a hedonist, so you have spotted something that I wanted to convey.

      My hope is that people will realize just what you said- you need to know what "truth" and "joy" are in order to obtain happiness.

      I think that everyone, deep down, acts in such a way that they think they will obtain the most happiness. Anyone who thinks that hedonism is invalid only does so because they think that that belief will bring them happiness.

      For me, finding truth is what makes me happy, so I am on a constant search for truth. In addition, you need to figure out what the rules of the universe are in order to know, as you said, what things like "truth" or "joy" are in the first place.

      -JTS

      Delete
  4. I wondered about how truth could be known 100% and spent my life writing a book to prove the truth 100% I succeeded in discovering the root of all truth and published it in my book on Amazon, called "You are Important."

    ReplyDelete